Woodward+SS+v.+Glenbrook+North+DP+-+Ohio+Valley+Doubles

The 2NR does everything almost perfectly.

I think that the 1AR has great vision on answering everything but conceding the perm theory is pretty damning in this debate. I think that if the aff doesn't do this - its a totally different round. The concession of the severance and intrinsicness theory is enough to reject the permutation meaning there is literally nothing on the CP. The aff concedes that the counterplan solves 100 percent of the affirmative and just needs a risk of the federalism net benefit to win the ballot.

As for the 2AR, I think you're putting too many eggs in this singularity evidence without really answering the 2nc analysis. I think the negative is doing a pretty good defensive job on this debate. I do think the New American card is pretty good as to how health care destroys federalism, but I think that Pappas is exactly right at all they ahve to do to win a risk of the CP solving federalism.

The singularity argument I think is mitigated by the conceded 2NC/2NR analysis as to why it is impossible, without singularity - the CP is more advantageous while solving the affirmative.