Rowland+Hall+AF+v.+Georgetown+Day+RS+-+Blake+Quarters

I think the debate is evaluated based on the assumptions created by the affirmative - I think that the 2NR is ahead on the alternative debate rather than the permutation actually solving. The 2NR analysis is on point when she gives the analysis on the alt debate accessing Hillman better.

I vote negative because I think the permutation has a solvency deficit - I think the 2NR analysis on the discourse debate is enough to cause some type of perm solvency deficit. I think that Becca’s analysis of how the permutation can’t really capture 100 percent of the mindset shift debate. I think that the role of the ballot is to choose which mode of politics is best -and I think the negatives intellectual criticism alt is the only way to overcome the justifications of the 1ac I also think it captures the external impact of Hillman best.  I think the Sparke evidence is pretty fantastic and indicts every Kagan warrant in the 2AR which this means the K can function as a turn to entire aff and also access a better way to sovle for peace - I think that the Sparke evidence gives an internal link into the interventionism impacts. 