Dunwoody+GG+v.+Chattahoochee+VZ+-+Carrollton+Round+5

The problem is in the 1AR and the lack of content on the States Counterplan. There is functionally no reason why the CP cannot solve the entire case. I think the negative is farther ahead on the capitalism debate - because the analysis of the Petras evidence is the same in every speech. You need to be building on the 2AC analysis. Apparently this card is pretty good, so take advantage of it. It postdates everything. My advice for the 2AR is to try and use some of these 1ar Case args on the counterplan debate about how the Petras has a federal key warrant (if it does). I think your time would be better spent doing this type of analysis rather than why capitalism is bad - because the work you're doing the CP can solve. I think the 2AR Hirsch analysis should be earlier in the debate on the States debate.

Jameson 5 (Frederic, Professor of Comparative Literature and Romance Studies – Duke University, Archaeologies of the Future: The Desire Called Utopia and Other Science, p. 147)